28 pages after the initial June 2022 post. And apparently no response from Microsoft.
Same issue for me. I've been using PCs for over 40 years; building them for about 25.
I well know that changing hardware can bollix the match between a PC and a Windows digital license. But it never occurred to me that updating the BIOS could be a problem.
I paid well over $200 for my Windows 11 Pro license. First a retail CD for Windows 10 home (about $100). I usually buy the OEM keys, but I had heard that retail keys were more robust, so I thought I would try one.
Then, I upgraded at a premium price (not sure, but over $100) for a Pro Upgrade directly from the prompt on the Windows System/activation screen. It was more expensive, but the transaction was convenient.
SLMGR still showed this as a retail key. But did not reveal any actual Pro key - just a generic one - which is not uncommon.
This was about two years ago. At the time, I made the mistake of not keeping a record of the upgrade transaction - never knew that I would ever need it.
I try to keep my PCs' BIOSes (UEFI these days) updated to get the latest security patches. A few days ago, in October 2024, I update the Bios on the ASRock Z590 Motherboard in my self-built system.
A few days later, I get the dread Windows is not activated watermark. The activation screen indicated that maybe I had changed hardware, but I had not done so. I tried everything I could think of based on years of experience - e.g., logging into and out of My Microsoft account, entering the default key from the BIOS, entering the original Windows 10 Home key, etc. (I don't think I ever got a separate key for the direct Pro Upgrade.)
I managed to get a MS support person on the phone. To her credit, she was polite and clear. We went through all the routine stuff. Did not work. And, after at least a half hour on the phone, she would not or could not reactivate my PC. She explained I needed to have kept the order number for the Pro upgrade a I bought about 2 years ago. And I just don't have it. So, from Microsoft's view, nothing would be done for me.
I need this machine every day, and I cannot mess around. I bought a new Pro key yesterday.
Today, I found this thread - because it just hit me that maybe the BIOS update caused the activation issue. Certainly, the MS tech support person never suggested it. Maybe, If I had thought of this earlier, I would have rolled back the BIOS and tried to re-activate. But probably not. Every BIOS re-write carries a little risk, and I do want the most secure BIOS possible.
Anyway, I am very unhappy about all this. I guess my take-away is never again to buy a retail key directly from Microsoft. Sure, OEM keys can fail too. But they cost less.