I am not an expert on setting up Domains, so I need to ask. Three of your user profiles seem to be on a Domain, while two are not. The log stops after the Carolyn situation but perhaps it just doesn't get to the other two. If you can remove that user from the Domain, maybe it would make a difference, not sure.
I also don't mess with User profiles, but I believe there is a process for creating a new user profile and transferring all the information over to the new user profile and deleting the old one. You might look over the link, and if nothing else, perhaps it would show what you need to duplicate to keep it safe. I have never done this process.