After a lot of testing, I have found that my screensaver works as long as I do not have my VKB-Sim_Gladiator_MkII Joystick plugged into the usb port. I did read that most of the time where this issue is happening, it's related to usb devices / ports and the power settings, or glitchy drivers.
That said, when I first built my new pc the joystick was plugged in and the screensaver worked just fine. I still think it has something to do with usb devices, but the issue is with MS drivers that are part of the OS. Maybe someday they will fix that and things can return to normal. For now I just leave the joystick unplugged and everything is working good now for about 2 months.