Old phone refusing to transfer Microsoft authenticator license to new phone

Jay F 0 Reputation points
2026-04-29T16:00:08.2266667+00:00

I recently purchased a Moto g stylus (2024) and am trying to transfer my information and liscense from my old phones authenticator to my new one. I went through the process of transferring liscense. I got the email from Microsoft saying my new phone was accepted and would be set as standard.

Instead, my old phone went "no." And refuses to transfer any information. It refuses to transfer the license to my new phone. My old phone does nothing to transfer the information regardless of how much I try to update it. Both phones were connected and turned on at the time of liscense transfer.

Microsoft Security | Microsoft Authenticator

1 answer

Sort by: Oldest
Most helpful Newest Oldest

  1. AI answer

    2026-04-29T16:00:23.37+00:00

    The behavior matches a situation where Microsoft Authenticator on the old phone is still the “active” device, so approvals and registration flows are effectively tied to it instead of the new phone.

    Use these steps and checks:

    1. Confirm which device is receiving prompts
      • When registering or signing in, the push notification is sent to the device where Authenticator was last used.
      • If the old phone still has a working Authenticator app, open it and check whether it is showing the approval prompt there instead of on the new phone.
      • If so, approve from the old phone once so the registration/transfer completes for the new phone.
    2. Remove the old device from the account
      • Sign in to the account’s security settings in a browser and remove the old phone as an authentication method so notifications stop going there.
      • The FAQ describes this as “Remove old devices” under the section about notifications going to the wrong device.
    3. Use an alternate verification method if locked out
      • If the old phone will not cooperate or is unusable, choose a different verification method during sign-in (for example SMS, if that is configured on the account) to complete sign-in and then reconfigure Authenticator on the new phone.
    4. Make sure the new phone’s Authenticator is healthy
      • Ensure the new phone has the latest Microsoft Authenticator version installed and that notifications and network connectivity are working, as described in the troubleshooting article (update the app, disable battery optimization for Authenticator, verify notification settings, and confirm date/time and OS updates).

    If none of the above works and there is no other verification method configured, tenant or account admins typically must reset MFA methods so they can be set up again on the new phone.

    References:

    AI-generated content may be incorrect. Read our transparency notes for more information.

    Was this answer helpful?

Your answer

Answers can be marked as 'Accepted' by the question author and 'Recommended' by moderators, which helps users know the answer solved the author's problem.