I have 8.1 and use AVG free edition and it has worked for me for years. Automatically updates and works just fine and NO viruses. Go to AVG website and download the FREE edition, they will try to sell you other but just watch your screen and get the free one. The download should go to your Desktop or Downloads folder, then you install it from there, very easy and a great anti-virus program.
As for Windows Defender, I understand it will NOT work if it identifies that you have OTHER antivirus software. In my case I had Win 8 - upgraded to 8.1 and the when the Win 10 became available I upgraded to 10. Then found out that it is a total SPY program and is sending info about you every minute of every day, I went back to 8.1 which I am using now, and it will only get an error if I try to activate Windows Defender anyway.
I have not used Defender for 2 years and don't miss it.
I trust AVG.
Bob