- On your keyboard, press the Windows logo and the letter R. It will launch the "Run" box.
- Type in "regedit"
- Now look for this string, HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows Search\FileChangeClientConfigs
- If you found it, right click on the folder and rename it to: HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows Search\FileChangeClientConfigsBAK
- Close the Registry Editor and rebuild your Index
As others have commented, the indexing of email in Windows 8.1 (Using Outlook 10) is a "real" issue and after several hours of searching I found this solution thread and indeed it worked immediately. Indexing in Outlook started! It does not require a reboot.
Thanks Kruger and others that suggested this rename fix to the Registry. For those concerned about touching the Register: Just follow Kruger's directions and you will be fine. There is one caveat, however, I won't know if it is a permanent fix for "awhile" will I?