Also, total sales of physical media actually apparently dropped.
DVD sales are dropping, which is normal because of the increase of Blu-ray and streaming;Blu-raysales increased 75% this year: ipcarrier.blogspot.com/2010/12/blu-ray-movie-sales-up-75.html
The whole point of Windows Home Server, Windows Media Center and Home Theater PCs is to play a library of ripped music and movies from a server to a TV, that's how they work best.
The problem is bandwidth. ... Ask yourself though, ..., if you could download movies for half the cost, ..., wouldn't it be more worthwhile?
Bandwidth is improving, so it won't be a problem for long, but there are many other problems that I mentioned, such as the lack of audio and subtitle tracks, and the limited choice of movies or TV series available.
As for downloads, or rather streaming since there is virtually no movie download offer anywhere, I have been an avid Netflix user for 7 years, switched to Blu-ray over a year ago and do a lot of streaming, but even Netflix is not so appealing to me now,
they don't add many new watchable titles available for streaming even on a monthly basis, and it's still anextremely limited choice compared to their DVD or BD mail offer. For me, streaming is more a way to discover
if movies are worth buying the disc than an enjoyable movie experience.
I assume you are using HDMI fully then? Once again, most monitors these days only include a DVI cable, which doesn't support HDCP. In fact, many 3D computer monitors being sold don't even support HDMI 1.4 for 3D (and only recent video cards support
3D over HDMI). The only person I know who uses Blu-Ray on their computer, has troubles because of the protection.
I use DVI for my monitor, HDMI for the computer-receiver-TV connection. I couldn't care less about 3D which is not a stable industry standard yet. As for copy protection, it's not a problem for playback, only if you want to rip BDs, but it's not specific
to Blu-ray, it's the same as for DVDs and some CDs (you rightly mentioned Sony rootkit.) I have been using AnyDVD to rip hundreds of DVDs and recently some BDs, never had any problem. Except that I am breaking the U.S. law each time because it somehow does
not recognize fair personal use.
Go visit the hardocp, wegotserved or other media forums, or even the Windows Home Server forum on this site, and you'll meet hundreds of people passionate about HD movies stored, not necessarily watched, on computers.
It's that as a multi-billion dollar company, you CAN'T sell a product with a kill switch controlled by a competitor, otherwise, you risk mass-lawsuits, looking incompetent
That's what user license agreements are for, Microsoft would naturally limit its liability to what it controls if it were to support Blu-ray playback. Their huge legal team will be way ahead of you there, don't worry about them. I worked for 13 years at
MS, I can assure you they take no risk!