Hi @Cole Aaron Wierzbicki
Could you provide a few details?
- What is your PowerPoint version? Please go to File > Account > About PowerPoint and share the version/build number.
- Does the Record button appear grayed out in all presentations or only one specific presentation?
- Is the presentation stored locally on your PC, or is it opened from OneDrive/SharePoint/Teams?
- When you mention the red Record button is grayed out, are you still able to click From Beginning or From Current Slide in the Record tab and start a recording session?

- Or does it show greyed out button here?

Please provide more information so I can assist you better.