Onenote: images are replaced with a red X

You're right.  I have the same result as you with your examples. Wikipedia is another secure site that saves pictures. 

The reason I thought about the secure /non secure is because I have 2 websites that use exactly the same structure.  The only difference (apart from the information on them) is that one is secure and one isn't.  One saves the pictures and the other doesn't

Sharon,

Glad that the comments have been helpful.

Your idea regarding secure/non-secure is interesting.  That would not have occurred to me.  My experience, however, is that some secure sites do work (e.g., Yahoo, MSN, and Huffington Post).  If you would, please check the secure URLs I mentioned in my earlier post to Luke and let me know if you have any problems with those links.

There are so many web development technologies available these days that the issue is probably a compatibility problem between the OneNote Clipper and one, or more, of those technologies.  If we could identify a list of problem sites someone who is knowledgeable about the technologies behind those sites could probably figure it out fairly quickly so I'm hopeful that Luke's proposed initiative will bear fruit.  I would have thought that the OneNote technical staff would have been all over this but I've seen no evidence that they are remotely interested in solving the problem.

Wayne

Thanks so much for writing everything out so clearly.  I have been experiencing the same problem and wondering what I had been doing wrong.

Your idea about the web coding got me thinking.  I have a few websites myself so experimented with them and have tried it with a few others.  Secure websites don't seem to save pictures but non secure ones do.  ie https websites don't save pictures but http ones do.

This may be a red herring - and it's difficult to find non secure sites but it would be great if it was that simple - and a quick fix could be made!!

Sharon

Luke,

Per my earlier note, here are a couple of links to try.  Both worked OK using Chrome and the "Article" option:

https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/opinion-lenz-billy-graham_us_5a8ef291e4b005bb0fef46ec

https://www.yahoo.com/news/tucker-carlson-turns-trump-apos-095039632.html

These are the Huffington Post and Yahoo. The first link I sent to you was for MSN.  

Following is a link from CNBC that doesn't work:

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/02/trumps-easy-win-trade-war-is-a-no-win-situation-for-wall-street-and-main-street.html

Generally speaking, I've found that sites either work or they do not.  I don't recall having any problems with MSN or Yahoo, for example.  I did a couple of quick tests today and the Huffington Post appears to be solid, as well.  CNBC on the other hand has never worked as far as I can recall. 

This is what makes me think the problem has something to do with the technology used by each website.  If you and/or some of your students are particularly techie you may be able to look at the website information (usually readily available in the browser) and draw some conclusions as to what development platform was used.

The following article, for example, provides information on how to access web page source code.

https://blog.kissmetrics.com/how-to-read-source-code/

Delving into that is above my pay grade, for sure.

Wayne

Luke,

Thanks for the update.  I'm glad to hear that the reference site clipped correctly.  I'm reasonably sure that I have others that will work and I'll post a few when I have a chance to run them to ground.

Having your students help is a great idea.  Can your students share a notebook?  If so, some system similar to what I'm using to track clips in OneNote might be a good way to build an extensive reference tool.  The only problem then would be finding someone in Microsoft who is actually interested in solving the problem.

Also, you could set up a shared Excel spreadsheet for tracking purposes.  I'm thinking a list of websites by row and the clipper options that work/don't work shown in columns.  That might produce a nice reference tool, as well.  It would also be easy to identify line items by student, something I'm not sure would be as simple to do in OneNote.

In any case, best of luck and please do post what you find.

Wayne