"I'm one of the designers on the OneNote team."
Omeed ~ I recently upgraded from v.15.29 to 30 and, once again, turned the experimental features on. But the new layout really doesn't look like "designers" were involved. It looks like some programmers, who don't appreciate the subtleties of the original
design, were given the task of moving certain elements to the left side of the window.
One of the original design's subtleties is the use of color to give context to the page being viewed. For example, the narrow strip of color under the tabs and all the color-shaded pages on the right (except the page being viewed.) The original designer
even thought to also color-coordinate the section and page names. Most users may not
consciously benefit from these color cues, but it's apparent that a real designer felt that users would at least
unconsciously benefit from them.
Such subtle color cues are missing from the new layout. ...It's as though a programmer (rather than a designer) simply didn't appreciate them enough to carry them over from the old layout.
Another example is the jarring effect from clicking on the new Search icon. It's hard to imagine that this was "designed" — it looks to be the work of a programmer who doesn't know much about interface design.
If you think the above is harsh, well, there are stronger words from others on the
feedback page. If the criticism there hasn't already prompted the OneNote for Mac team to bring in some real, experienced designers to review the new layout, then we've been wasting our time giving feedback.
õ¿õ¬