Scheduling and managing events using Outlook.com calendar
I think I'm just beaten into submission at this point. There are a couple of additional clicks, and the cheese was moved. But I'm fairly able to create appointments out of emails now. At the very top of the screen, click the calendar with a check box (think its called Outlook Today or something). Then you can drag your email to the resulting window and you get the appointment window with the email details. Hope you find peace in additional clicks.