I thought I had waited long enough move to Win 11...apparently not.
TL;DR I was wrong. Same problem.
Search Indexing is critical for me & something I use all day long. I have 20 years' worth of documents, emails, presentations, raw code, etc. that could have what I'm looking for anywhere or nowhere at all. At any time, I may need to find something within the entirety of those files or to know that something is specifically not there. Roughly 100gb just in Outlook files.
Typical search(s): 45-75 seconds, or much longer. With indexing: <5 seconds. If I get lots of hits, maybe 10 seconds.
Some searches would have to be broken up to multiple different parts of the system: RegEdit to search the registry, Win search to search all documents, multiple Outlook searches, individual database searches and on & on. Or indexed takes me <10 seconds. That means that when I'm on the phone with a client (or anyone else) I likely have the indexed search result for the topic of their question before they finish asking the question. Or I can find that 1 sentence that was "in there, somewhere" from 15 years ago but never made it in to a finalized document.
As the poster has said Win 11 indexing looked fine upon install. I recall the 1st indexing took about 2x longer (may have been longer; finished overnight) than I was used to but chalked it up to it being the 1st indexing. I didn't notice an issue for about a week. Then everything in this thread came true.
Part of why indexing is so useful is that I don't know what file might contain what I'm looking for. Could turn out to be anything, even Windows or program files. When it takes 1-2 seconds to find out if your search target even exists, your workflow is not broken. When I know its going to take roughly 1-5 minutes to search though everything in order to hope that there is NOT something there dampens my use of searching at all. If I choose to include the entire registry this process is basically a deal killer.
Off to find a 3rd party tool...again.
P.S. Sorry to readers for the long rant. But Microsoft? Come on! No wonder people look at me cockeyed when I tell them I've used indexed search since the day it was offered. Most don't know what I'm talking about and that's 100% b/c issues like this that prevent typical users from ever having an interest in a tool (that you already build!) that could save them significant time & headache.