It's something in the user account controls.
Do these both have local Admin accounts enabled or multiple user accounts?
Unfortunately, the person who did a new build didn't respond as to whether it was an upgrade or a fresh install since an upgrade from 10 might have the local admin enabled.
I logged into the local admin on mine and saw an error about the password change requirement, which was previously set to never expire, so I am leaning towards a change in the group policy from the update. After I reset the policies, just through the user account control, to never expire password, etc. I haven't had further issues.