I'm replying to myself in case anyone has my issue, I found another thread talking about Registry.
Here's what they said:
"I've seen issues where uninstalling a printer's software doesn't always do it cleanly, can leave entries in the Registry, have had it happen when I went from an OfficeJet 8021 to an OfficeJet 9015, I just ignore the chance to update the older drivers until I get a chance to clean the Registry by removing all references to them"
I went into the Registry Editor app and deleted anything mentioning the printer and now it's gone!!