<snip> All the instructions for different ways to shutdown to close programs are meaningless.
I think that last statement was going a little far. At least there are workarounds until MS gets its act together.
Using different shutdown methods or a shutdown script aren't workarounds for the two situations I have mentioned (laptop battery dying or unplugging because of scareware). Wouldn't that clearly make those instructions meaningless for both those circumstances?
For a couple of rare-use cases, you are correct. Statistics don't favor the individual.
My assumption is that a frozen or unresponsive system, which re-opens the applications that froze the system in the first place, is the primary"-use case". And definitely the more pertinent/serious one.