It doesn't just change the icon - it changes the program. Yes - it only occurs on my PC, not my laptop - but I don't unzip packages of files on the laptop. There are other replies to this thread - and other threads - where this is occurring on others machines. It shouldn't be ignored and dismissed as a setup issue. It is not a setup issue. There has to be a registry setting SOMEWHERE that is flagging these applications to go back to Microsoft's "recommended" applications. It doesn't occur with applications where Microsoft does not have a recommended application.
Again - as I have stated, ad nauseum, if I open one of the thousands of zip files I get annually containing .mp3 files using WinZip - I will see them with the Windows Media Player icon - and if I open one of those .mp3 files from the zip file, it will play using Windows Media Player. If I extract those files, they will change automatically to Groove Music. That triggers all other files back to Microsoft recommended file types. .pdf files change from Adobe Reader to Edge; video files change from VLC to Windows Movies & TV app. AGAIN - I have circumvented the issue by using WinRAR to extract my files.
If it was just one type of file being changed, then I could be persuaded to agree that it was a setup issue - but it is not. I have over 20 years of desktop support experience and I know how to change a default program. With Windows 7 and previous Windows O/S - I NEVER saw anything like this occur. NEVER. I have see the registry hack to fix this issue - adding OpenWith "". It only works temporarily. Again - which is why I am no longer using WinZip to extract my files. Regardless - the trigger is the automatic changing of the .mp3 files from Windows Media Player to the default Groove Music that changes the other files to the Windows recommended program.
I have provided enough information to Microsoft and in this thread for someone smarter than me - someone who knows the O/S a lot better than I do - to be able to find whatever setting in the registry is that is causing the issue.
Finally - WinRar is now my default zip program. If I happen to right-click on a zip file and open with WinZip and extract my files, it will change my default zip program from WinRar to WinZip.