Taking a clue from the reply of Readhead\_Sailor in this thread:
I’ve just found some further corroboration for my analysis in these Norton Community threads – so if you folks ever manage to pull out of the tailspin that you’re in, then the information here might prove helpful:
Microsoft Defender Definition Update Failing:
https://community.norton.com/en/forums/microsoft-defender-definition-update-failing
Norton install does not set Defender keys to properly disable:
https://community.norton.com/en/forums/norton-install-does-not-set-defender-keys-properly-disable
Also note that the links provided by Readhead\_Sailor are bad, and should be edited by a moderator.
[Edit for update, 5/23/2016]
Norton users who are experiencing the Windows Defender definition update issue should definitely have a look at the solution brought to us by hughie55 in this Windows discussion thread:
This procedure appears to be resolving the issue by setting the correct values in the Windows Defender registry key – and thus avoiding the need for any direct editing of the registry.
[Edit for update, 5/30/2016]
So are we making any progess here, people? My apologies to McAfee users – I missed this one on my previous search:
https://community.mcafee.com/thread/89280?start=0&tstart=0
[Edit for update, 6/11/2016]
Short, non-technical explanation for the prospective fix:
Completely disabling your third-party AV app; starting Windows Defender; and then enabling the third-party app (while Window Defender is still turned on) should disable Windows Defender in exactly the same way that reinstalling the third-party app would:
1.) Completely disable the third-party AV app in its interface.
2.) Start Windows Defender
3.) Enable the third-party AV app
So like it or not guys, we now have a potential solution that’s easy as 1-2-3; that completely resolves the issue, and that only takes a minute (more below).
GreginMich