Backing up " User " data is trivial and not focus of this thread. Anyone can simply drag and drop folders or files from one location to another.
If all one wants to do is backup pictures, music, documents, ( files ), then system image backup isn't necessary.
Purpose of system image is to backup " Whole " system in case of disaster or should one want to upgrade to a faster or larger drive.
So while I agree you can inspect and look at " User " files primarily, there's no way to know which system files and binaries may be needed or could be restored when system misbehaves badly, application is corrupted, or worst drive dies...
Even if you could identify a system file or binary that had problem, rarely ever will you be able to simply drag and drop one system file and get an application to work or system to boot, etc...
I'm of the opinion whatever works for one is correct solution.
For me I want something that works flawlessly, 100% of time with minimal effort on all my windows platforms ( hardware, software, operating systems ).
System Image Backup has never, ever worked for me once.
While I've been able to perform successful System Image Backups in the past, I've never been able to simply, plug in recover disk and restore System Image Backup to a brand new drive and have the system boot afterwards or if it did boot, come up with same
exact configuration, including the hidden partition that most vendors include the original system configuration from factory, plus OS.
Something was always missing and since I didn't know how extensive the differences were I would basically have to reinstall Windows from scratch and re-install all applications again which could take days, even weeks. And many of the application configurations
and settings ( browser, word processors, spreadsheet, video and sound editing, program editors, virtual machine software, etc... simply could not be reconfigured from memory...
***************************************************************************************
So for all of you who like System Image Backup, great...
... Just make sure you've confirmed you can restore complete image to same or different disk and system boots as expected...
I wouldn't recommend recovering to same disk, because if it fails at all, you lose everything.
And most people will not do following because of time, expense, effort and / or lack of knowledge:
- purchase separate disk to practice on
- create system image backup
- create recovery or boot disks
- remove original drive from system
- install new / practice drive in system
- boot off recovery disks
- restore system image backup to practice disks
- confirm it's working
***************************************************************************************
For me, I would like to see MS create cloning feature so I could clone to an external disk, boot off of external cloned disk, then later swap it with internal disk in laptop should need arises.
Highly unlikely they MS will ever do that because of Monopoly Laws and software vendors complaining.
If MS did implement a superb functioning backup and cloning built in apps that work 100% of time then there would be no need for after market and third party software which would cause hugh anti-trust and monopoly lawsuits...
Again, find whatever works and stick with it until something better comes along.
Acronis True Image isn't without faults. From reading threads, only cloning works without glitches, rest of the features, file backups, partial file backups, differential backups, etc... are highly flawed. I wrote an extensive letter to Acronis about this
issue and they acknowledge and confirm there's work to be done...
Better release a package that has less features and they all work ( have been tested and QA ) than to have lots of features that don't work...