It's just a shame it seems to be designed primarily for touch screen phones / pads etc , but is still bundled with all new laptops sold in the UK.
Well it's primarily designed for Tablet PCs, which is both: A laptop and a Tablet. And the two "worlds" makes sense in such devices.
It works well with the mouse. I connect my Surface Pro to a 19" Monitor if I'm at home and I use a bluetooth mouse and a full blown keyboard. The feature that I use most is the snapped view, which is really better than the old Windows docking system (I don't
mean the Win 7 snap).
I never had a problem like accidentally activating the charms before.
Some complains I can really understand, some I don't. The start-button-orb for example. Some people just prefer static buttons instead of hidden button. This should be optional.
People simply are complaining about stuff even though it's there. Like printing in the mail app. or forwarding email. They complain that its not possible. But you cant use an OS without knowing the concept. Printing and forwarding was always there. If you
know the concept of Win 8, then you will find these stuff easily.
If you decide to use MacOS or Linux instead of Windows, you have to learn the concepts of this systems too. In MacOS you have to know that the menu are always in the top bar for example.