You didn't get the point... Doesn't surprise me as I have seen it too many times. There is sometimes a give and take there, I suppose. The point of the reflection is you should read what you stated out loud and imagine *I* said it.
My responses to you merely pointed out your opinion is not the only one (and the outcome of the 'experiments' depend on more factors than you may have originally accounted for *if* they were to be performed on the stage this all is playing out on) and that those who may be satisfied *could* outnumber the ones that are unsatisfied. Especially given that many do not bother to find a place and brag on a product - but many will find a place and try to break one down. Even more so in a place where everyone goes to get issues resolved. The, "Hey doc! I made an appointment just to let you know I am feeling fine, nothing wrong." *shake hands and leave* scenario rarely happens.
I came up with counterpoints to the points (experiments) you felt had to be mentioned... well, because you brought them into the conversation. Or, I asked what you were trying to imply with the mention of a given experiment. I could have ignored them - but that might have been rude. You brought up the PhD (amongst other credentials). You brought up the experiments and the comparisons. It (all) could have been left out, but...
Anyway - to sum up what I have seen on the opposite side of this discussion...
Jump in head first, get a third party start menu, use a local account, turn on autologon, turn off the lock after sleep and use a different email application than the built-in one and Windows 8 is now more like Windows 7 all without the only choice being the tile start menu (still there - but the classic is back too), removing the need for a Microsoft account, eliminating the pesky logon security and not using the tablet-like email application (that does, yes, reflect back on how the Android and Apple devices in the same category work - meaning you have to have a Google or Apple account to use some parts of them) and do it all with a little haughtiness.
I did get all your points only I think you did not get any of mine nor the points of others...
this is supposed to be a room for complaining and asking for help and not for being enamoured with the product..
just read the number of headlines in the general forum that start with "I hate Win 8". If you want to read comments about how much people love Win 8, read a forum that is titled with that... this isn't it.
What you are also forgetting or are ignorant about since you never asked is whether we who ended up with a computer wanted to have the Win 8 on it at all.... I did not want Win 8... Win 7 was perfect for me and would have loved to buy the laptop I bought with Win 7.. if it were available! The quality of the computer I needed for the price I wanted to pay for it came with it.. I had no choice about it. Thus I have the right to "not like" what OS I got given that I did not want that in the first place.
Thus it is not the case that I "bought" Win 8 and now I don;t like it but rather I bought a computer that CAME with it and I don't like it... but I have no way of getting out of it.
Sometimes a bit of more information asking can be helpful... my resistance to your statements came from this--and this realization just came to me now.