As an end-user, this is a thoroughly frustrating thread. This is what it sounds like to me:
Uh, hi, how do I provide feedback/ideas to Microsoft.
You just use one of the various mechanisms provided for input.
Well, some of them don't seem appropriate for just giving feedback/ideas when I don't want support.
Well, you just pick the right one for what it is you're doing and what it is you want to convey.
Yea, but with so many options, it still doesn't seem like there is one that just lets me give feedback/ideas and that I have to do a lot of looking around to find something and, even if I find one quickly, I'm not sure it's the right
one.
Well, take a risk and try them. Trust us that someone is monitoring them.
Having a potential plethora of ways to comment and/or get support doesn't necessarily equate with having a simple mechanism for giving product input that gives me, the end-user, the supposedly important person that Microsoft wants to empower, confidence
that my input is going to the correct place. Think of it from an end-user's perspective: if you give me a hundred ways to provide input and some of them clearly don't end up where I want (such as wanting to provide input on Excel itself and not feedback
on the web site for Excel), I'm going to tend to not be confident that I'm using the correct mechanism or that my feedback really is going where I want it.
The last few posts here by the people seeking to provide feedback are clear that they are trying to provide feedback (think new feature ideas, ideas on how current features could work better, frustrations with current features or the lack thereof that can
help Microsoft develop better products). They aren't trying to get support/answers. The various Microsoft mechanisms tend to be geared toward providing support/answers or for getting feedback for something I just did in a program (such as using help in Excel)
or looking up information on a web site, not toward getting random feedback/ideas on things the user isn't necessarily even currently doing (such as, oh, I was using Excel two weeks ago and I had this great idea on how to make charts simpler; I finally have
time to send in my idea; oh, but wait, where do I write up my thoughts and whom do I send them to).
For Microsoft employees on this thread, if you want to see an example of a single portal that would be similar to what the end-users here have been suggesting, please talk with the Office sustaining engineering team. I used to work for Microsoft and was
the Lead for a team of engineers who created such a site for customer support. That site was for getting real users' issues into our system so we could address them. Something like that could easily be adapted for the purpose the end-users on this thread
desire. If I remember correctly (since we built the site a few years ago and I retired from Microsoft earlier this year), one of the reasons we built that site was because input could come in from various sources in various ways and we needed one place to
funnel that information through to enable the appropriate people to see all the issues coming in and to make decisions on whether or not we were going to address any particular issue.
Perhaps I'm wrong, but it seems to me that a Microsoft Feedback and Feature Request portal could be quite simple. It doesn't seem like it would require much more than controls to drilldown to which product you want to comment on (perhaps, for example, a
dropdown list of Office versions--such as Office 2013 and Office 2016--and a dropdown list of platforms--such as Windows, Mac, Android), controls to gather user information such as name and email address, and an edit box to provide the desired input. The
backend could route the input to the appropriate product team. An end-user might then be able to search the site for input they've given in the past and see what, if anything, was done in response to their input. Of course, you might want to provide other
product/feature drilldown capabilities; I'm just giving a simple example.
Such a site would not be for an end-user to get support/answers. It would just be for providing feedback/ideas.
My two cents... I hope it helps clarify things. :-)