most used applications should be pinned to the desktop taskbar anyway, so I fail to see how that example is realistic. it takes me the same time to open any application on w8 or w7.
start // type// enter.
or
its pinned to the taskbar
if you say that you need to scroll the start screen, you'd also need to scroll the start menu for other programs... why do you think that this is faster? it isn't.
as for the average home user, most of them have the funniest reasons to say they don't like it. I especially like the ones that say "W8 is **** because it doesn't have the same games like it did before". really? also, most people just go towards the peer
pressure thing. if the interwebs says it sucks, they believe it and give it no chance nor any attempt to learn how it works. it then becomes cool to hate. also very visible on these forums is people being very vocal about "missing functionality" that they
simply haven't bothered to try to find. "this is shiiiiiiit" they say. then you point out where things are, and they either don't come back or find another thing to complain about, as they feel their pride is hurt.
its a very interesting sociological phenomenon...someone should study it.