Very Simply...no more Hearts, I want a 1-5 scale in someway at least. If you want to keep your cute hearts just let me rate from 1-5 or 1 - 10.....anything hearts, bunnies, stars, musical notes, I'll let some marketing genius at MS pick the rating icon of there choice, that's why they make the big bucks.
So tired of a all or nothing broken/unbroken heart rating system!!
Don't get me wrong, I agree that a 5-star system is much better than the overly simplified system in place now, but what are your reasons for wanting a more granular system?
Is there any need to have songs rated in such a way? I can't imagine making a playlist of songs that I 'like a little' or 'like a lot but aren't my favourites'. Or is it simply so you can keep more detailed information on your collection?
Would you use the ratings for something else, such as a customised way of categorising music (e.g. 3 stars are 'driving songs' or 4 stars are 'mellow songs' or something)? If that's the case, wouldn't a different improvement, such as more detailed access to metadata, be more useful?
I currently use the heart system in this sort of way. My favourite songs are given hearts, songs that I don't really want to listen to (mostly alternate versions, remixes, demos, etc.) are broken hearts, and everything else is 'no heart'. I can then make autoplaylists using ratings and genre to give me control. It's not perfect, but it's pretty good.