Andrea, glad the wheel mod worked for you. I might well cut the peg out on mine as well, but I don't want to do that until I'm sure the scrolling is fixed.
Meanwhile, the scrolling saga continues...
Having been away all week, and used my mouse for the first time tonight, the scroll still didn't feel quite right, it was still skipping occasionally.
The screw was as loose as it could be without the case rattling, so I thought I'd try and work out what effect the loose or tight screw was having.
As I mentioned above, the scrolling mechanism itself is worked by a "star wheel" which turns in between an (I guess) infrared LED and a light sensor. As the pins of the wheel break the light beam this is sensed as the wheel turning.
To cut a long story short, my experiments brought me to the conclusion that the problem is that the wheel sits slightly too low in between the light and sensor, so that sometimes the light is shining on the hub of the wheel and so the beam doesn't get
to the sensor.
This would explain why the case screw being too tight causes a problem if it pushes the wheel downwards.
The height of the wheel is determined by a tab at the back of the wheel which presses down onto a microswitch to work the "middle mouse button" press. The wheel is hinged at the front and lifts up easily.
What I did was to add small pieces of paper - I used a post-it note so they stuck there - one one top of the other to build up a stack and thicken the tab, hence lifting the wheel. I think I used about 6 or 8 pieces in the end to make the mechanism work
well. You can keep the batteries in the mouse while you are doing this so you can test it.
Once I was happy with the height, I tidied the stack by trimming the edges then taped it in place and reassembled the mouse.
It's feeling better still this time, seems to be scrolling very smoothly. The "middle mouse" click is a bit "sudden" now, but I hardly ever use this so it doesn't trouble me.
I'll give it a few days and see if it carries on working, if I have any more problems I'll report back - watch this space!