Hi Mike,
I have the same problem as everyone else. Scrolling stops working, so I fold the mouse down, then up again, to reset it and pair it again with my Surface Pro 3. Then, scrolling works again for a little while, and stops, requiring another mouse reset, etc.
I've tried un-pairing it to the Surface and then pairing it again, using different batteries, and playing with mouse settings, all to no avail.
I originally purchased my Arc Touch Surface Edition mouse from Best Buy as an "open box" item, which means that someone had previously purchased it but returned it a short time later. The store gives a 5% discount for such items, so I decided to purchase
it to see how it would compare to my Logitech t360 mouse. I prefer the Arc Touch mouse; it's easier to hold and I like that it's flat when turned off. It's easier to put into small cases, much easier to hold and move, and less slippery than the t360. The t360
constantly needs to be charged. The Arc Touch is a lot better in that regard.
After buying the Arc Touch, I assumed that it would work and that I didn't need any of the packaging, so I through it out. I didn't use it much for the first couple of weeks that I had it, but once I began using it, I experienced the scrolling problem constantly.
Today, I happened to be near a Microsoft retail store, so I decided to ask them about the problem.
As soon as I told them that I'd purchased the mouse at Best Buy, they said that they couldn't help me and that I should call 1-800-MICROSOFT. When I called, I got through to a guy who told me I'd reached the wrong department, and said that he'd transfer
me to the right one. In doing so, he somehow disconnected me. I called back and spoke with a second person, who logged an issue and gave me the issue number for reference. She told me to take it back to Best Buy and that they should be able to replace it.
She said that I should give them the issue number to refer to, if they needed it.
When I took it back to Best Buy, a woman in their customer service department said that because it had been more than 15 days since I'd purchased it, and Best Buy doesn't have an agreement with Microsoft on warranties for the mouse, they couldn't do anything.
I called 1-800-MICROSOFT again, and their automated call routing system misdirected my call. The guy that I spoke with transferred me to the right department.
When I spoke with a fellow named Ruben, I explained the problem, he e-mailed me, I replied with a link to this thread, and he told me that they'd replace the mouse and FedEx me one within 5 to 8 business days. From start to finish, it took me about 3.5 hours
to get Microsoft to agree to replace the mouse.
While I agree that this isn't a software problem, but a hardware flaw, I'm not sure if it's mechanical or electrical. It might be a flawed haptic actuator. Because customers have experienced this for over four years now, Microsoft's hardware engineers must
know about it. Perhaps it's not a design flaw, but a sporadic manufacturing flaw that causes some of the mice to exhibit this problem, and they haven't been able to fix the manufacturing problem or fixing it would cost more than to just risk it and replace
any defective mice reported by users. I suspect that a lot of users don't want to deal with the inconvenience and Microsoft never hears from them.
Whatever's going on, it's a shame that Microsoft hasn't publicly acknowledged the problem, because there are lots of reports about it from many different users across various countries. I really hope that when I get the replacement mouse, it'll work. If
not, I'll have to give up on the Arc Touch mouse and revert to using either the Surface's trackpad or my Logitech t360 mouse.
Best Wishes,
Steve