Hi JaseStafford,
Thank you for reaching Microsoft Community.
Kindly try these steps below to troubleshoot the issue on your Surface Earbuds and see if the issue persist:
1: Check if the correct audio profile is selected
Click the Audio icon on your Taskbar (for Windows 10)
Make sure that Headset (Surface Earbuds Hands-Free) is selected
*For Android/IOS: since audio can be heard in the earbuds, the Surface Earbuds profile is already selected. Please proceed to step 2.
2: Check Equalizer settings
Open your Surface Audio app. select Equalizer
Set the Choose a preset to Flat
3: Restart app or audio source
Close and re-open the application you are using
4: Turn the earbuds off and on
5: Restart host device
Restart your Windows 10 or android device
6: Check if a firmware update is available
Please see Update Surface Earbuds page
7: Reset Surface Earbuds
Please see Reset Surface Earbuds **** page
8: Try to pair to another device
Try pairing your earbuds to another host device and see if the issue persist
If the issue occurs on the other host device, the problem is likely a hardware issue
If the issue does not occur on the other host device, check the host device for updates
For hardware issue, you may contact support through this page: Contact Us or through our Global Customer Service phone numbers to check for replacement options available.