Hey Karlie, thanks for answering to my problem. I did do what you recommended. Since we have two IPs set as Main and Backup/2nd i have two different yet similar results. I am starting to see a possible issue?
On the First IP (Main) I ran "tracert" with no additional options. My results looked good at the beginning. Hops one through seven started off with one millisecond of latency to as high as four milliseconds by the time it reached hop seven. Hop eight through twelve, "Request Timed Out", and finally hop thirteen it reached its destination (AWS) with 31ms. I did run a second test just to see if results varied but the were consistant.
On the Second IP (Backup/2nd) I ran the same command with no options. The results were the following; Hops one through four increased from one millisecond to four. Hop five through eleven, latency increased from 17ms, sky rocketing to 53, and back down to 40 before hops 12 through 18 timed out. The trace was complete by hop 19 with 70ms.